Marcello Mulero B.
Posted
I tested The Trading Analyst for two…
I tested The Trading Analyst for two months, and honestly, it’s not as good as it looks. There are a few things that most people probably don’t notice, but they’re really not okay. First of all, the Momentum Trades — they’re not good. When you buy the program, they show you a trading history of around 100 trades with only about $500–600 in profit overall , which is very low. Many of those trades actually hit stop loss. The Swing Trades, on the other hand, are pretty solid. You only get maybe one or two alerts a month, but they’re usually reliable, and the win rate is quite good. Now, what’s total scam and nonsense is the Scalping part. After I emailed them, they told me they had made over $4,000 in profit since I joined — which is simply not true. I took every single trade they sent, so I know exactly what the results were. Sometimes they send an entry alert early in the morning that only a few people see, and then they quickly delete it from the Telegram channel. That way, it looks like everything is in profit when others check later. This happened to me several times — I’d get an alert on my Apple Watch, take the trade, and when I checked 30–60 minutes later to see if they posted an exit, the entry alert was suddenly gone. Not once or twice, but around five to ten times. Because of this, I went from being up around €70 to being down €10, just because they delete trades that go wrong. So if you’re thinking about joining mainly for Momentum Trades, I honestly don’t recommend it at all. If you only want Swing Trades, then fair enough — they’re decent and consistent, even if you only get a few per month. But for Scalping, be very careful.
Response from The Trading Analyst· Nov 7, 2025
Hi Marcello, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with The Trading Analyst. We truly appreciate your feedback and are sorry that our service wasn’t the right fit for you. We take every review seriously, especially when it comes from someone who has spent time testing our alerts and systems. At The Trading Analyst, we provide three types of alerts to serve different trading styles and risk levels: - Swing Trade Alerts, - Momentum Trade Alerts, - ES/NQ Scalping Alerts. Each system is distinct and has its own rhythm, goals, and risk profile. Swing trades are the foundation and the core of our program. They are designed to capture larger market moves over several days or weeks and are naturally less frequent, typically two or three per month depending on market conditions. We are glad you found these reliable, as they continue to be the most consistent and long-term focused part of our service. Momentum trades are more frequent and designed to capture shorter-term moves using near-term options contracts. This style comes with higher risk but also greater potential for short-term gains. That is why we usually play these with tiny position sizes. Regarding the Scalping Alerts, this system was introduced in June 2025 and operates automatically, generating between 5 and 30 alerts daily, including overnight sessions. It trades short-term moves in ES and NQ futures, which means it runs continuously. Occasionally, during futures contract rollovers, the system may post trades that are not valid due to technical anomalies such as large gaps or duplicated entries. When that happens, we manually remove those trades to keep results realistic and accurate. None of these deletions were to hide losing trades. In fact, the few removed trades were winning signals that appeared due to contract-switch gaps and would have created false and unrealistic profits if left in the record. We are proud of our transparency. Our results are tracked in real time and fully visible to members. This week we are also adding a dedicated Scalping Tracker so members can review every single trade and performance metric directly. Since launch, this strategy has accumulated more than $18,500 in profits based on standard position sizing. We understand that different traders have different expectations and risk tolerances, and we are sorry that your experience was not as positive as you hoped. Your feedback is very helpful and will be shared with our team as we continue to improve. If you would like to discuss your experience in more detail or review specific trades together, please reach out to us at [email protected]. We are always happy to clarify and assist. Thank you again for giving The Trading Analyst a try, and we wish you the best of luck in your trading journey. Warm regards, The Trading Analyst Team