Excellent
1,126 reviews
Small Pet SelectSmall Pet Select delivers the freshest hay, as well as food, bedding, snacks, and more for rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, and other small animals. We also carry hard-to-find items for dogs and cats!
Small Pet Select (smallpetselect.com) has 1,126 customer reviews on Consumer Courier, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
1,126 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Jaclyn
Posted
Small Pet Select is the only hay that is consistently high quality and the only hay my little bunny prefers! I’ve been ordering for years and couldn’t recommend enough! Thank you for all the care you put into putting out such a great product!
SUSAN D.
Posted
My order was shipped out quickly and accurately. The product, chicken treat hanging bar, is of good quality.
Jeannette
Posted
This order was an attempt to correct the problems with the 3 cutting hay but he absolutely hates the 1st cutting. I even tried to mix a few pieces with his 3rd cut and he literally picks it out and pushes it away. It has been several days with the same unwanted results.Your response neglected to point out that I have contacted you on two occasions. Once, I sent a picture and second, I sent an envelope in the mail with a sample of the 3rd cutting that is almost a “dust” like quality that is a huge quantity of the 10 lb box that is completely inedible and must been thrown away. If it is “hand” packed, how is it possible no one seems to notice? His health along with avoiding any blockages is my main concern. His droppings reduced to a very small size after his attempt to forge on the new box. His veterinarian agrees with me at his recent yearly checkup that he needs something other than those small pieces to keep his gut moving. I thought by trying the 1st cut to “blend” with the 3rd cut would add in his digestion and get him back on track. I have seen results when he consumes the longer pieces, the droppings go back to their normal size. All you offered was a small discount on the next order. I have been with you folks for a long time so I have been through multiple seasons of hay growing seasons and/or issues but never like this.
Response from Small Pet Select· Jul 17, 2026
Hi Jeanette, Thank you for giving our hay another try for Mr. Bugs. Every bunny has their own favorite texture and taste, and it sounds like he's made it very clear that First Cut isn't his top pick! 🐰 Looking at your order history, we noticed that this was your first time trying our 1st Cut Timothy Hay after previously ordering 2nd and 3rd Cut. We love that you were willing to see if Mr. Bugs might enjoy a little variety, even if he had other plans. Since every rabbit has their own preferences, it can sometimes take a little trial and error to find their perfect match. If you ever have questions or would like help choosing the best cut for your bunny, we're always happy to help. We didn't hear from you after this order, but we'd have been glad to offer guidance. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience, and we hope Mr. Bugs continues to enjoy his favorite 2nd and 3rd Cut hay. Wishing you both all the furry best! Small Pet Select
Catherine
Posted
The only hay my bunny will eat! High quality products. Great customer service and fast shipping. I love the little small pet postcards they include in the hay boxes. Highly recommend Smart Pet Select.
cavy G.
Posted
The hay looks great, not too choppy and hopefully not too much dust at the bottom :)
Fish
Posted
Fast delivery, got everything I ordered, and my bunnies loved them!
Andrew O.
Posted
Just started ordering hay from Small Pet Select probably 3-4 months ago. I wish I had done it sooner. The hay has been flawless and our piggies wheek every time I give them some. Plus, they occasionally throw some freebies in with it. I use the subscription service, it’s been convenient and reliable.
Vidette
Posted
Kept informed about arrival time and the hay looks beautiful! Thanks!
