Evalynn D.
Posted
Valvoline hires incompetent individuals.
I normally don’t leave reviews, but this situation has been extremely serious and ongoing, and I feel obligated to warn others about my experience with Valvoline in Medina, Ohio (Route 18 location). I brought my 2016 Mini Cooper Countryman S in for a routine oil change. At the time, the vehicle was fully drivable. Immediately after leaving the shop, my car began experiencing severe issues — extreme RPM fluctuations, shaking, and near stalling — and broke down shortly after. The vehicle had to be towed and inspected by an independent repair shop. Their diagnosis indicated that something was improperly handled during the oil change, with evidence suggesting foreign material or an error related to the oil filter system that caused catastrophic damage to the turbo and engine. The repair estimate is approximately $13,000. What is most concerning is not just the damage, but how this situation has been handled. I filed a claim with Valvoline and was initially told they wanted to “make it right.” However, once the cost of repairs became clear, the claim was denied without any clear or consistent explanation. Since then, my family and I have made multiple attempts to get answers. We’ve received conflicting statements from management, no formal written reason for denial, and no accountability. When we went in person simply asking for clarification, the interaction became dismissive and unhelpful. At this point, my vehicle has been unusable for over a month, and we are left dealing with the financial and logistical consequences of what appears to be a preventable error. I strongly urge anyone considering service here to proceed with caution, especially if you have a vehicle that requires specific care or expertise. This experience has been incredibly frustrating, expensive, and disappointing.